End of Line Distortion Measurements
Steve Temme discusses the importance of detecting manufacturing-induced defects such as Rub & Buzz, Loose Particles, and other distortion measurements during end-of-line testing and explains the various algorithms that are used. He compares conventional and perceptual metrics for the measurement of Rub & Buzz, including Listen’s new enhanced Perceptual Rub & Buzz algorithm, and discusses why it can be beneficial to use both conventional and perceptual measurements in tandem.
INDUSTRY FEATURES
End-of-Line Distortion Measurements
Steve Temme focuses on various test methods, and introduces Listen’s newest perceptual distortion algorithm, comparing it to other conventional and perceptual techniques in this article about distortion measurements.
It is important to catch speakers with Rub & Buzz and transient distortion defects at the end of the production line, as such defects sound harsh and quickly give the impression of poor quality. These manufacturing-induced distortion defects are easy to screen for, but what exactly should you be measuring? In this short guide to end-of-line distortion measurement, we discuss various test methods, and introduce Listen’s newest perceptual distortion algorithm, comparing it to other conventional and perceptual techniques.
What Causes Rub & Buzz and Loose Particles
Rub & Buzz and Loose Particle faults are pretty much exclusively introduced during the manufacturing process. Rub & Buzz is usually caused by small aberrations in the manufacturing process that make some parts rub or rattle when the speaker is operated, such as off-center voice coils, poorly glued surrounds, or incorrectly trimmed lead wires. This can be a random manufacturing issue with one product, or a drift in production line characteristics over time. Loose particles are caused when foreign particles, such as glue or magnet fragments, become trapped in the gap behind the diaphragm or dust cap during the manufacturing process.
Conventional Detection Methods
Although Rub & Buzz, and Loose Particles sound different to the trained ear than they do to the average consumer, both manifest themselves as an annoying vibration sound that may be more prominent at certain frequencies and worse at higher output levels. Despite this similarity, the detection methods are very different. Rub & Buzz is a periodic distortion effect. Conventionally, it is measured using Higher Order Harmonic Distortion (HOHD) analysis, examining typically the 10th order harmonic and above. These harmonics contribute most significantly to Rub & Buzz as their separation from the fundamental frequency makes them less masked and more easily detected by the ear. There are several widely used measurement methods. A high-pass filter algorithm is common, but has its limitations as it combines all the harmonics into an overall metric, and does not distinguish between periodic and transient distortion. Other methods sequentially measure individual harmonics using a tracking filter that moves from one harmonic to the next. While this technique provides accurate and detailed information on each harmonic, it is not fast enough for use on automated production lines.



